Official 2007 Trade Rumors

[missionhockey21]

Either way, I see a lot of pissed off people. Dunn's contract will allow him to stay a Red next season should the Reds pick up his option, and I think Dunn feels loyalty to the Reds for the contract, working with him and bringing a hitting coach in for the primary reason of working Dunn. He's been our top run producer and therefore valued when you get past the people who complain about strikeouts or defense (that is improved this season), not to mention he is still 27. To get the value for what we would lose, Padres fans would be ticked off. Then again if the Padres believe that Dunn will surely opt for FA and the Reds buy that, Reds fans will be less than happy with the return. That is pretty much any trade involving Dunn though in a nutshell and sadly I see myself contemplating a team switch if I have to be a victim of yet another poor trade by our sorry GM.

[HollywoodLeo]

I tried to team switch once, back in the early 90s when Tom Werner was selling everyone off to the lowest bidder.

I found myself too emotionally attached to the Padres to change, though.

(Ironically enough it was the Gary Sheffield-Trevor Hoffman trade that I labeled the "final straw")

[padrefanforever]

Originally Posted by HollywoodLeo Chase Headley is a small price to pay to get Dunn in this line up. And we obviously aren't missing Clay Hensley at all.

Headley isn't a small price if he's included with Hensley in a deal that would simply get us a rental for a few months.......Keep in mind Leo......it's not worth it to me if Dunn option is voided......if we get Dunn for two seasons, and the price is the above mentioned......I'm down

[HollywoodLeo]

If the trade was made and the Padres proceeded to win the World Series, with Dunn contributing like we think he would, but then Dunn walked....I'd think it was worth it.

But that's the risk they'd be taking because Dunn naturally wouldn't guarantee winning anything.

[padrefanforever]

I'd like to make all my decisions based on hindsight too then

[HollywoodLeo]

Originally Posted by padrefanforever I'd like to make all my decisions based on hindsight too then

That's the perks of being armchair GM fan.

[padrefanforever]

Well then let it rip and I'll decide if I was pro or con after the season is over.....lol.....


If we get Dunn and don't win the WS, and p/u his option, and in Apl. next year he blows his knee out....then walks at season end after only getting 50 AB's in '08.............is it worth it still ?

[padrefanforever]

By the way.....it's nice to see you in here for more than a short stint....

[HollywoodLeo]

Originally Posted by padrefanforever By the way.....it's nice to see you in here for more than a short stint....

I check these boards a lot, just don't always have something to respond to.

I'm also all over strike3, not just the Padres forum.

[padrefanforever]

cheater

[love_that_reefer]

So no more Bard love affair since you guys now want Salty from the Braves? Dunn is a good possibility if the padres are smart about and guarantee Dunn a contract before the trade along with Hensley and someone else.

[padrefanforever]

I like Bard......but if you have an opportunity to get what could be a future superstar backstop......and you happen to have what the team he's blocked on might want......you'd be stupid to not at least make a run at him.......If we don't get him......I'm VERY ok with continuing on with Bard.......

Salty will be bigger, stronger a better hitter, hit for more power, has a cannon for an arm, and plays great defense......

I'd say Bard is pretty avg across the board with a plus being he's a decent switch hitter